Balance Hypothesis (balance + hypothesis)

Distribution by Scientific Domains


Selected Abstracts


Influence of atmospheric carbon dioxide enrichment on induced response and growth compensation after herbivore damage in Lotus corniculatus

ECOLOGICAL ENTOMOLOGY, Issue 3 2002
Alain Bazin
Abstract 1. Plant growth and chemical defence compounds in four Lotus corniculatus genotypes exposed to factorial combinations of ambient and elevated carbon dioxide, and herbivory by caterpillars of Polyommatus icarus were measured to test the predictions of the carbon/nutrient balance hypothesis. 2. Shoot and root biomass, allocation to shoots versus roots, and carbon-based defence compounds were greater under elevated carbon dioxide. Pupal weight of P. icarus was greater and development time shorter under elevated carbon dioxide. 3. Herbivory decreased shoot growth relative to root growth and production of nitrogen-based defence (cyanide). Young leaves contained more defence compounds than old leaves, and this response depended on carbon dioxide and herbivory treatments (significant interactions). 4. Genotype-specific responses of plants to carbon dioxide and herbivory were found for the production of cyanide. Furthermore, maternal butterfly-specific responses of caterpillars to carbon dioxide were found for development time. This suggests the existence of genetic variation for important defence and life-history traits in plants and herbivores in response to rising carbon dioxide levels. [source]


The carbon,nutrient balance hypothesis: its rise and fall

ECOLOGY LETTERS, Issue 1 2001
J.G. Hamilton
The idea that the concentration of secondary metabolites in plant tissues is controlled by the availability of carbon and nitrogen in the environment has been termed the carbon,nutrient balance hypothesis (CNB). This hypothesis has been invoked both for prediction and for post hoc explanation of the results of hundreds of studies. Although it successfully predicts outcomes in some cases, it fails to such an extent that it cannot any longer be considered useful as a predictive tool. As information from studies has accumulated, many attempts have been made to save CNB, but these have been largely unsuccessful and have managed only to limit its utility. The failure of CNB is rooted in assumptions that are now known to be incorrect and it is time to abandon CNB because continued use of the hypothesis is now hindering understanding of plant,consumer interactions. In its place we propose development of theory with a firm evolutionary basis that is mechanistically sophisticated in terms of plant and herbivore physiology and genetics. [source]


Plant ontogeny and chemical defence: older seedlings are better defended

OIKOS, Issue 5 2009
Arnaud Elger
Although patterns of seedling selection by herbivores are strongly influenced by plant age and the expression of anti-herbivore defence, it is unclear how these characteristics interact to influence seedling susceptibility to herbivory. We tracked ontogenetic changes in a range of secondary metabolites (total phenolics, alkaloids and cyanogenic glycosides) commonly associated with seedling defence for nine sympatric British grassland species. Although there was marked variation in concentrations of secondary metabolites between different species, we found a consistent increase in the deployment of phenolics, alkaloids and cyanogenics with seedling age for six of the seven dicotyledonous species examined. The two grass species by contrast exhibited low levels of secondary metabolites across all developmental stages, possibly due to an investment in structural (silica phytoliths) defence. Our results corroborate species-specific patterns of seedling herbivory observed in field studies, and offer some explanation for the relatively high sensitivity to herbivore attack frequently observed for relatively young seedlings compared with their older conspecifics. Our results also support predictions made by the growth,differentiation balance hypothesis regarding ontogenetic changes in resource allocation to anti-herbivore defence for a range of potential chemical defences and across a range of sympatric plant species presumably subject to broadly similar selective pressures at the regeneration stage. [source]


Intraclonal variation in RNA viruses: generation, maintenance and consequences

BIOLOGICAL JOURNAL OF THE LINNEAN SOCIETY, Issue 1 2003
SANTIAGO F. ELENA
This paper explores the evolutionary implications of the enormous variability that characterizes populations of RNA viruses and retroviruses. It begins by examining the magnitude of genetic variation in both natural and experimental populations. In natural populations, differences arise even within individual infected patients, with the per-site nucleotide diversity at this level ranging from < 1% to 6%. In laboratory populations, two viruses sampled from the same clone differed by ,0.7% in their fitness. Three different mechanisms that may be important in maintaining viral genetic variability were tested: (1) Fisher's fundamental theorem, to compare the observed rate of fitness change with the extent of fitness-related variation within the same experimental populations; (2) magnitude of genomic mutation rate, to assess whether it correlated with fitness-related variation, as predicted by the mutation-selection balance hypothesis; (3) frequency-dependent selection, which affords rare genotypes an advantage. The paper concludes with a discussion of two evolutionary consequences of variability: the fixation of deleterious mutations by drift in small populations and the role of clonal interference in large ones. © 2003 The Linnean Society of London. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2003, 79, 17,26. [source]