			Home About us Contact

Select Committee (select + committee)

Distribution by Scientific Domains

Humanities and Social Sciences	20%

Selected Abstracts

Interpreting the Process of Change in Higher Education: The Case of the Research Assessment Exercises

HIGHER EDUCATION QUARTERLY, Issue 1 2003
Ted Tapper
Given that the current Research Assessment Exercise (RAE 2001) has been completed, it is an appropriate time to explore the impact of the RAEs upon the character of British higher education. This timeliness is reinforced by the earlier publication of HEFCE's own ,Review of Research' (September 2000), the report from the House of Commons' Select Committee on Science and Technology Committee (April 2000), with a report due in April 2003 from the Joint Funding Bodies (under the auspices of Gareth Roberts). We are therefore in a period of review and consultation, which may culminate in a new assessment regime or, as its severest critics would hope, even its demise. While our analysis genuflects to these contemporary developments, it is constructed within a framework that interprets the RAE process as constituting a continuous struggle for the control of the production of high-status knowledge. [source]

The Treasury and Civil Service Select Committee during the Thatcher Administration

PARLIAMENTARY HISTORY, Issue 2 2007
PETER J. LAUGHARNE
First page of article [source]

Latest news and product developments

PRESCRIBER, Issue 6 2008
Article first published online: 24 APR 200
Government responds to NICE report The Government has published its response to the Health Select Committee's report into NICE, broadly arguing that the Committee's recommendations are either already being dealt with or are not appropriate. The Committee recommended appraisals for all new drugs, shorter, rapid appraisals to coincide with their launch, and improved mechanisms for setting drug prices. The Government says its negotiations on the PPRS preclude a detailed response but suggests a rapid system may not be transparent or legally robust. It is exploring how high-cost drugs can be brought within the payment-by-results tariff. While defending NICE's reliance on QALYs, the Government accepts the need to explore how wider economic factors can be considered. As for the threshold cost per QALY by which NICE defines cost effectiveness, it says this is being validated scientifically and NICE will continue to determine the threshold. More topically, the Committee criticised the quality of clinical trial data available to NICE. The Government sees no need to compel pharmaceutical companies to disclose information and says NICE is already becoming more involved with research programmes. All clinical trials must be registered (confidentially) with the EU and the Government believes mandatory registration in the UK would be ineffective and illegal. Prescription charge up again from April The Government has raised the prescription charge by 25p to £7.10 per item with effect from 1 April. Prescription prepayment certificates will cost £27.85 for three months and £102.50 for 12 months. The increase, below the annual rate of inflation for the 10th successive year, will be levied on the 12 per cent of prescriptions that are liable for the charge: 5 per cent via prepayment certificates and 7 per cent from other prescriptions. The charge will generate £435 million in England in 2008/09; this excludes money from prescriptions written by dispensing doctors, which is retained by the PCT. Following criticism of the charge by the Health Select Committee, the Government says it has reviewed the charge and is now consulting on ,cost-neutral' options. MHRA safety update The MHRA warns of possible dose errors associated with Boots Medisure Domiciliary Dosage System in its latest issue of Drug Safety Update (2008;1:issue 8). One case has been reported in which incomplete sealing allowed tablets to mix between compartments. No other cases are known and the MHRA says no harm was reported but the risk is serious. The system should be carefully sealed and inspected visually and physically. The MHRA reaffirms its plans to reclassify all pseudoephedrine and ephedrine products to prescription-only status in 2009 if the new restrictions on sales do not reduce misuse. Other topics in this month's Update include revised indications for oral ketoconazole (Nizoral), restricting its use to selected conditions unresponsive to topical therapy; reformulation of the injectable antibiotic Tazocin (piperacillin plus tazobactum); the risk of peripheral neuropathy associated with pegylated interferon and telbivudine (Sebivo) in the treatment of hepatitis B; and serious adverse events associated with modafinil (Provigil). First oral anticoagulant since warfarin In January this year the EMEA issued a positive opinion to recommend marketing authorisation of the oral, fixed-dose, direct thrombin inhibitor dabigatran etexilate (Pradaxa) for the primary prevention of venous thromboembolism (VTE) in adult patients that have undergone elective knee or hip replacement surgery. Marketing authorisation for the EU (including the UK) is expected from the European Commission in the next few weeks, making dabigatran the first oral anticoagulant since warfarin was introduced in 1954. Dabigatran etexilate has been shown to be as safe and effective as enoxaparin (Clexane) with a similar adverse event profile in the noninferiority phase III RENOVATE (Lancet 2007;370: 949-56) and RE-MODEL (J Throm Haemost 2007;5:217885) trials, which investigated the efficacy and safety of dabigatran compared to enoxaparin in reducing the risk of VTE after total hip and knee surgery respectively. Dabigatran has the practical advantage over low-molecular-weight heparin of oral postoperative administration and no risk of heparin-induced thrombocytopenia and, unlike warfarin, does not require monitoring or dose titration. Risk scale predicts anticholinergic effects US investigators have developed a scale for predicting the risk of anticholinergic side-effects from older patients' medicines (Arch Intern Med 2008;168: 508-13). The scale assigns a score from 1 (low) to 3 (high) for the risk of anticholinergic effects such as dry mouth, constipation and dizziness associated with commonly prescribed medicines. Checking the scale retrospectively in older patients in residential care, a higher score was associated with a 30 per cent increased risk of side-effects after adjustment for age and number of medicines. When this was repeated prospectively in a primary-care cohort, the increased risk was 90 per cent. HRT cancer risk persists The latest analysis of the Women's Health Initiative (WHI) trial of HRT shows that the small increase in the risk of cancer persists for up to three years after stopping treatment (J Am Med Assoc 2008;299:1036-45). WHI was stopped after 5.6 years' follow-up when it became clear the risks of HRT outweighed its benefits. This follow-up after a further three years (mean 2.4) involved 15 730 women. The annual risk of cardiovascular events was similar for HRT (1.97 per cent) and placebo (1.91 per cent). Cancers were more common among women who had taken HRT (1.56 vs 1.26 per cent), in particular breast cancer (0.42 vs 0.33 per cent). All-cause mortality was higher, but not statistically significantly so, with HRT (1.20 vs 1.06 per cent). Tight glycaemic control may increase falls Maintaining HbA1C at or below 6 per cent with insulin is associated with an increased risk of falls, a US study suggests (Diabetes Care 2008;31:391-6). The Health, Aging and Composition study involved 446 older people with type 2 diabetes (mean age 74) followed up for approximately five years. The incidence of falls ranged from 22 to 30 per cent annually. Comparing subgroups with HbA1C of ,6 per cent and >8 per cent, an increased risk of falls was associated with insulin use (odds ratio 4.4) but not oral hypoglycaemic drugs. Copyright © 2008 Wiley Interface Ltd [source]

Latest news and product developments

PRESCRIBER, Issue 2 2008
Article first published online: 11 FEB 200
NICE should evaluate all new medicines NICE should determine the cost effectiveness of all new medicines, the Health Select Committee has concluded in its second review of the Institute. The review, prompted by criticisms from patients, health professionals and the pharmaceutical industry, found that NICE is doing ,a vital job in difficult circumstances'. The Committee called for the costs to carers and society to be included in cost effectiveness estimates (this is currently prohibited) and for cost per QALY thresholds to be aligned with NHS affordability. NICE should publish brief appraisals at the time of a product launch , these could be used to negotiate prices. GPs responsible for unlicensed co-proxamol GPs who prescribe co-proxamol are now responsible for the consequences, the MHRA warns. The Agency agrees that the drug may be needed by ,a small group of patients who are likely to find it very difficult to change from co-proxamol or where alternatives appear not to be effective or suitable'. Following the withdrawal of product licences, stock that is currently in the supply chain may be dispensed but no new stock should be released by suppliers. The Drug Tariff price of co-proxamol has now increased from £2.79 to £20.36 per 100 tablets. Vitamin D deficiency on the increase Pregnant and breastfeeding women may need vitamin D supplements, the Department of Health has warned, and GPs are seeing increasing numbers of patients with vitamin D deficiency. Endogenous synthesis may be low in some ethnic groups and dark-skinned people, and north of Birmingham there is no light of the appropriate wavelength for the synthesis of vitamin D during the winter. The Department says free vitamin supplements are available for eligible patients through its Healthy Start Scheme (www.healthystart.nhs.uk) and may also be supplied at low cost by some PCTs. Innovation and good practice recognised Innovative practice and better outcomes for patients have been recognised through awards from the NHS Alliance and Improvement Foundation presented by the Secretary of State for Health, Rt Hon Alan Johnson, at the annual NHS Alliance conference held in Manchester. The Mountwood Surgery in Northwood, Middlesex, won the CHD QOF GP Practice Award sponsored by Schering Plough for their outstanding multidisciplinary approach to tackling CHD. In addition to having a highly organised in-house cardiology team, they have produced an interactive, patient-empowering booklet for CHD. Mountwood Surgery achieved blood pressure targets of 96.79 per cent in their CHD patients. North Tees PCT wins the CHD QOF PCO Award, also sponsored by Schering Plough, for their support and encouragement to GP practices to ,own' CHD care. They provide timely feedback of performance data using funnel plots and regular communication by the CHD LIT and Cardiac Network. Even though North Tees PCT has a high CHD prevalence, 4.2 per cent vs 3.6 per cent nationally, across the 27 practices 85 per cent of patients achieved cholesterol targets and 91 per cent reached the QOF blood pressure target. The St Benedict's Hospice Day Centre Project (for the Sunderland Teaching Primary Care Trust) won the Guy Rotherham Award for its excellent multidisciplinary team improvement of the palliative care provided. This team demonstrated a thorough understanding of the use of quality improvement methods to improve patient care, and carefully measured the individual improvements they made. Through the use of a referral ,decision tree', nonattenders were reduced by 300 per cent and average waiting times halved. The Extended Primary Care (EPC) Gynaecology Service (for the Practice Based Commissioning Consortium South Manchester Hub) was highly commended for its development of an effective and innovative service offering gynaecological treatment managed within a primary care setting, allowing patients improved access closer to home. The Salford Perinatal Mental Health Project was also highly commended for effectively challenging the high levels of maternal suicides. The awards were also supported by Prescriber, the British Cardiac Patients Association and the British Cardiac Society. Anastrozole superior to tamoxifen in long term A new analysis of the ATAC trial (Lancet Oncology 2008;9:45-53) shows that the advantages of the aromatase inhibitor anastrozole (Arimidex) over tamoxifen as adjuvant therapy for breast cancer persist for at least four years after the end of treatment. After primary treatment with surgery, chemotherapy or radiotherapy, postmenopausal women with localised invasive breast cancer were randomised to five years' treatment with anastrozole or tamoxifen. Among 5216 women who were hormone-receptor positive, anastrozole increased disease-free survival by 15 per cent after 100 months. Time to recurrence and distant recurrence were also increased, though overall survival was similar; the absolute difference in time to recurrence was greater at nine years (4.8 per cent) than at five years (2.8 per cent). Joint symptoms and fractures were more frequent with anastrozole during treatment but not thereafter. Use a steroid with a LABA , MHRA reminder The MHRA has reminded clinicians that patients treated with an inhaled long-acting beta-agonist (LABA) should also use an inhaled steroid. In the latest edition of Drug Safety Update (2008;1:No.6), the Agency reviews the implications of the SMART study (Chest 2006;129:15-26), which reported an increased risk of respiratory- and asthma-related deaths among patients using salmeterol (Serevent). This is contradicted by epidemiological data suggesting that asthma-related admissions have declined since LABAs were introduced. Randomised trials also do not support such a risk, probably because inhaled steroids are used more consistently in trial settings. The latest Update notes that product licences for carisoprodol (Carisoma) have been suspended due to concerns about the risk of abuse and psychomotor effects. It also includes a comprehensive summary of drug interactions with statins, a warning that methylene blue should not be prescribed for a patient taking a drug with serotonergic activity, and a reminder that only oral formulations of desmopressin are now licensed for primary nocturnal enuresis. This issue of Update is available at www.mhra.gov.uk. Copyright © 2008 Wiley Interface Ltd [source]

Latest news and product developments

PRESCRIBER, Issue 4 2007
Article first published online: 3 APR 200
Low-dose aspirin may reduce asthma risk Low-dose aspirin may reduce the risk of new-onset asthma, according to a US analysis (Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2007;175:120-5). Prompted by speculation of such a link, the authors conducted a post-hoc analysis of the Physicians' Health Study, a placebo-controlled study of aspirin 325mg on alternate days involving 22 071 men aged 40-84. The risk of developing a new diagnosis of asthma during the five-year study was reduced by 22 per cent (p=0.045) among those taking aspirin. However, the number of cases was low: 113 among aspirin recipients and 145 with placebo. The clinical importance of this finding is therefore uncertain, though it received wide coverage in the lay media. Lifestyle changevsdrugs in type 2 diabetes Modifying lifestyle is at least as effective as drugs in delaying the onset of type 2 diabetes in people with impaired glucose tolerance, according to a study from Leicester (BMJ online. doi: 10.1136/bmj.39063.689375.55). The meta-analysis of 17 trials involving 8084 participants found that lifestyle change or orlistat approximately halved the risk of progressing to diabetes, whereas oral hypoglycaemic agents reduced the risk by 30 per cent. A Chinese herb, jiang tang bushen, reduced the risk by two-thirds. The analysis was conducted before the findings of major trials of rosiglitazone (Avandia) , DREAM and ADOPT , were published. Optician prescribing The diagnosis and treatment of disorders such as conjunctivitis by opticians is to be an enhanced service that PCTs can commission according to local need, a Department of Health review has concluded. The General Ophthalmic Services Review considered new arrangements to support PCTs provide ophthalmic services. Professional representatives proposed that the diagnosis and treatment of some eye conditions should be classed as ,additional services' that PCTs should be obliged to commission. While the Department agreed that opticians can play an important role, it found a lack of evidence of benefits and concluded that PCTs should be able to determine their level of services. A commissioning toolkit has been produced to help implement the review's findings. Warfarin stroke risk A four-fold increase in warfarin use has been linked with an increased incidence of intracerebral haemorrhage in a US study (Neurology 2007;68:116-21). Reviewing all first admissions for haemorrhagic stroke in the Cincinnati area, the study found that the proportion of cases associated with warfarin or heparin increased from 5 per cent in 1988 to 9 per cent in 1993/94 and 17 per cent in 1999. The annual incidence among patients aged 80 or older increased from 2.5 to 46 per 100 000 from 1988 to 1999. During the same period, warfarin distribution increased four-fold and there was no change in the incidence of thromboembolic strokes. Co-proxamol will go, MHRA reaffirms The MHRA has confirmed that it still intends to withdraw co-proxamol from the market despite protestations from MPs. The issue was raised by two MPs , one a member of the Health Select Committee , in a House of Commons debate. Both called for the withdrawal process to be abandoned, arguing that GPs should have the right to prescribe a drug for which there may be no alternative. The MHRA has restated its view that the risk from overdose with co-proxamol outweighs its benefits, adding: ,The avoidable death toll from co-proxamol overdose cannot be ignored. Sometimes regulation has to balance the needs of the individual against the benefits at a population level. In this case the removal of marketing authorisations with continued use possible in exceptional circumstances is the best balance that could be achieved. The public health gain is already becoming apparent.' Co-proxamol may still be prescribed as an unlicensed drug after its product licence is withdrawn at the end of this year. Guide to pharmacy services A guide to community pharmacy services has been published for patients, carers and members of patient organisations. Developed by the South East Local Pharmaceutical Committee Forum, Understanding and Making the Best Use of Community Pharmacy explains what pharmacies offer and the services available under the 2005 pharmacy contract. Copies can be downloaded from www.psnc.org.uk/resources. Little benefit from opioids for back pain There is little evidence that opioids relieve chronic back pain but the risk of abuse is high, according to a US analysis (Ann Intern Med 2007;146:116-27). The systematic review of trials of oral, topical and transdermal opioids in the treatment of chronic back pain found no trials lasting more than 16 weeks. There was no significant reduction in pain in placebo-controlled trials and limited, nonsignificant pain reductions in comparative trials. By contrast, estimates of prevalence of current substance misuse were as high as 43 per cent and that of ,aberrant medication-taking behaviours' ranged from 5 to 24 per cent. Dual antiplatelet therapy with drug-eluting stents Patients with drug-eluting stents should not stop dual antiplatelet therapy prematurely (Circulation 2007; published online 15 January; DOI: 10.1161/CIRCUL ATIONAHA.106.180944). Although 12 months' treatment with low-dose aspirin plus a thienopyri- dine, eg clopidogrel (Plavix) and ticlopidine, has been shown to reduce cardiac events after implanting a drug-eluting stent, it is not uncommon for the thienopyridine to be discontinued. Health professionals must do more to educate patients about their treatment and the risks associated with stopping. Scottish approval The SMC (www.scottishmedicines.org.uk) has approved varenicline (Champix) for use within NHS Scotland as part of a smoking cessation programme; it notes that the benefits of extending a course of treatment beyond the initial 12 weeks are modest. Controversially, the SMC has not approved omalizumab (Xolair) as add-on therapy for severe persistent allergic asthma on the grounds that an economic case had not been made. Asthma UK criticised the decision as unjust and inhumane. NICE is due to publish an appraisal of omalizumab later this year. No decline with anti- psychotics Treatment with anti- psychotics does not hasten cognitive decline in patients with Alzheimer's disease, say investigators from London (J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2007;78:25-9). Their prospective study of 224 patients found no difference in the rate of cognitive decline in those treated with antipsychotics (atypical or otherwise) for at least six months. Label translation online Health IT consultancy Rxinfo has developed a website offering translations of the most common types of labelling. The site (www.translabel.co.uk) offers translations into 13 Asian and European languages for 15 standard labelling phrases covering oral medicines and ENT formulations. A free application can be downloaded to allow direct-to-printer printing. Copyright © 2007 Wiley Interface Ltd [source]

Stem Cells, Superman, and the Report of the Select Committee

THE MODERN LAW REVIEW, Issue 4 2002
Roger Brownsword
First page of article [source]

Governance in Government: A Modest Proposal

THE POLITICAL QUARTERLY, Issue 2 2005
NICK MONCK
This article recalls evidence in the Hutton and Butler reports about changes in decision-making procedures in government, including the role of Cabinet and of the Cabinet Office in supporting collective decisions; and the failure to circulate papers on Iraq to Cabinet or to use a cabinet committee. The government`s response has been largely intelligence-specific and evades the wider criticisms. This article makes the modest proposal that Parliament should impose standards of governance on governments that broadly match those already imposed, with government support, on the boards of private sector companies (based on the Combined Code of Corporate Governance and the Companies Act 1985). It would make sense for the Select Committee on Public Administration to work out and publish a specific proposal. The government would be asked to report after a year on action taken to improve governance standards. This proposal should be pursued after the election. [source]

Government report highlights management and communication failures at STFC

ASTRONOMY & GEOPHYSICS, Issue 3 2008
Article first published online: 13 MAY 200
The report of the Innovation, Universities, Science and Skills Select Committee sets out in robust, plain language, a damning summary of the Science and Technology Facilities Council's handling of its funding problems over the past few months, highlighting "a poorly conceived delivery plan, lamentable communication and poor leadership, as well as major senior management misjudgements". [source]

Competition in the food marketing chain

AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL & RESOURCE ECONOMICS, Issue 3 2000
Garry Griffith
Competition in the Australian food marketing chain is of continuing concern, but little evidence is available to guide policy debate. In a search for broad guidelines, the theoretical and empirical evidence is reviewed and the recent report of the Joint Select Committee on the Retailing Sector is examined. Then publicly available data on several food groups are used to test for evidence of persistent market power. The purchasing behaviour of the grains and oilseeds processing sector is found to warrant more detailed attention. A possible research agenda and a call for greater attention to data requirements complete the article. [source]

A new department, a new minister , and a new select committee

ASTRONOMY & GEOPHYSICS, Issue 4 2009
Article first published online: 20 JUL 200
Science and technology is now part of the newly created government Department of Business, Innovation and Skills, with Lord Mandelson in overall charge. What will this mean for UK science? [source]